lundi 31 août 2015

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sarah Fasha

← Previous revision Revision as of 21:37, 31 August 2015
Line 31: Line 31:
 
* Any person can speak at a TEDx event this completely not true [[ Bill Clinton ]] and [[ Bill Gates ]] were not any person
 
* Any person can speak at a TEDx event this completely not true [[ Bill Clinton ]] and [[ Bill Gates ]] were not any person
 
** Finally the main idea of the page that she is Actress and Miss Egypt not about YouTube or TEDx so this should be kept.[[User:Davidwiki12|Davidwiki12]] ([[User talk:Davidwiki12|talk]]) 16:07, 31 August 2015 (UTC)
 
** Finally the main idea of the page that she is Actress and Miss Egypt not about YouTube or TEDx so this should be kept.[[User:Davidwiki12|Davidwiki12]] ([[User talk:Davidwiki12|talk]]) 16:07, 31 August 2015 (UTC)
Replying To Davidwiki12: Bill Clinton and Bill Gates spoke at [[TED_(conference)|TED]], not a TEDx event. TEDx events are non-notable independent events (which is what Sarah spoke at). Her TEDx talk (as most TEDx talks) did not receive strong coverage from multiple notable/reliable sources. TEDx and TED are completely different and mutually exclusive events. Literally anyone can set up a TEDx event (not a TED event). Furthermore, Wikipedias guidelines for notable people ( http://ift.tt/1KA2cqw ) require SIGNIFICANT coverage from multiple reliable strong sources. Sarah does not have this. Simply being covered by unknown magazines and websites is not enough to be an entry on Wikipedia. The references/sources in this article are very incredibly weak with no notable/known magazine reporting on anything about her. Doing my own research and still could not find any notable/reliable source reporting about her. Also to note, Ahmed Mohi El din (person who made strong keep vote above) created the article and made the vast majority of edits to the article, and is most likely a [[Wikipedia:Conflict_of_interest|Wikipedia Conflict of Interest]] to keep the article. [[User:Megat503|Megat503]] ([[User talk:Megat503|talk]]) 20:57, 31 August 2015 (UTC)
+
Replying To Davidwiki12: Bill Clinton and Bill Gates spoke at [[TED_(conference)|TED]], not a TEDx event. TEDx events are non-notable independent events (which is what Sarah spoke at). Her TEDx talk (as most TEDx talks) did not receive strong coverage from multiple notable/reliable sources. TEDx and TED are completely different and mutually exclusive events. Literally anyone can set up a TEDx event (not a TED event). Furthermore, Wikipedias guidelines for notable people ( http://ift.tt/1KA2cqw ) require SIGNIFICANT coverage from multiple reliable strong sources. Sarah does not have this. Simply being covered by 1 or 2 unknown magazines/websites is not enough to be an entry on Wikipedia. The references/sources in this article are very incredibly weak with no notable/known magazine reporting on anything about her. Doing my own research and still could not find any notable/reliable source reporting about her. Also to note, Ahmed Mohi El din (person who made strong keep vote above) created the article and made the vast majority of edits to the article, and is most likely a [[Wikipedia:Conflict_of_interest|Wikipedia Conflict of Interest]] to keep the article. [[User:Megat503|Megat503]] ([[User talk:Megat503|talk]]) 20:57, 31 August 2015 (UTC)


via Chebli Mohamed

Aucun commentaire:

Enregistrer un commentaire